Silverlight vs Flash: Double Click Difference on Timer, Enter Frame, Dispatcher Timer and Composition Target
Jan 09

As promised before, I will make a Flash version after implementing the 3D Image Rotator in Silverlight.

The Silverlight version is implemented using Kit3D while the Flash version is made by Papervision3D. Personally, I love the Silverlight sample more since it looks smoother. However, I think Papervision3D is much more easy to understand and utilize.

By the way, the images used in the Flash version are taken from my graduated school - The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. Hope you will like it~

Demo

Source codes

Flash

Silverlight

Shares and Enjoy~

Did you like this post?

Subscribe here:  

11 Responses to “Flash vs Silverlight: Kit3D vs Papervision3D Example”

  1. Dan D Says:

    In order for this to be an accurate comparison you would have to use the exact same images for both examples. Further more, the Silverlight image dimensions are smaller. Great work though!

  2. Blah bla Says:

    It seems that the Silverlight implementation shows a distortion along the top of ALL the images!

  3. Tiago Andrade e Silva Says:

    Hi!
    Suggestion for another of your posts: How about creating a application that captures the images of a video (or the entire aplication) like the one that this site does in Flash: http://www.jag-jeans.com/

    congrats on your site :)

  4. na Says:

    i really dont understand why anyone is bothering with microsoft silverlight … realy i dont

  5. re-flex Says:

    Here is a simply 3D engine for Silverlight ;)

    http://silverlighter.ru/blogs/hotdog/archive/2008/12/13/silverlight-amp-3d.aspx

  6. Kit3D - ein 3D C# Grafikengine für MS Silverlight at Programming with Silverlight, WPF & .NET Says:

    [...] Den Vergleich sieht man auf ShineDraw. [...]

  7. Silverlight Cream for January 09, 2009 -- #480 Says:

    [...] Flash vs Silverlight: Kit3D vs Papervision3D Example [...]

  8. Silverlight vs Flash (Shine) | CISNKY Says:

    [...] felt the comparisons are sometimes not controlled. For example, the images and sizes used in the Flash vs Silverlight: Kit3D vs Papervision3D Example are [...]

  9. Kyle Says:

    Hi,

    I just started using Kit3D to develop a 3D chart component, however I have browsing the web for almost 2 days and still have no clue how I can put a text in my chart component.

    Does anyone know how I can convert a text into a ModelVisual3D object so I can add it under Viewport3D to allow 360 degree rotation?

    Please help and thanks in advance

    Kyle

  10. Top-silverlight » Blog Archive » Flash vs Silverlight: Image Slide Show using Perspective 3D Says:

    [...] Flash vs Silverlight: Kit3D vs Papervision3D Example (9) [...]

  11. alex Says:

    how do i make it start without the user clicking “click here to start”

    thanks

Leave a Reply